Amazon's Alexa could soon speak in a dead relative's voice, making some feel uneasy

June 23rd, 2022

Amazon Echo and Echo Plus devices behind illuminated Echo Button devices during an event by the company in Seattle in September 2017. (Elaine Thompson/AP)
Elaine Thompson / Elaine Thompson

Do you miss the sound of a dead relative’s voice?

Well fear not: Amazon unveiled a new feature in the works for its virtual assistant Alexa that can read aloud in a deceased loved one’s voice based on a short recording of the person.

“While AI can’t eliminate that pain of loss, it can definitely make their memories last,” said Rohit Prasad, senior vice president and head scientist for Alexa, on Wednesday at Amazon’s re:MARS conference in Las Vegas.

In a video played at the event, an Amazon Echo Dot is asked: “Alexa, can Grandma finish reading me ‘The Wizard of Oz’?”

“OK,” Alexa’s voice responded.

“Instead of Alexa’s voice reading the book, it’s the kid’s grandma’s voice,” Prasad said. “We had to learn to produce a high-quality voice with less than a minute of recording.”

He added: “We are unquestionably living in the golden era of AI, where our dreams and science fiction are becoming a reality.”

Indeed, the feature immediately drew comparisons to fictional depictions of technology, but ones bleaker than what Prasad was likely referencing, like “Black Mirror,” the dystopian television series that featured an episode in which comparable technology was deployed.

The feature is still in development, and Amazon would not say when it might publicly launch, but its preview comes at a moment when the cutting-edge capabilities of artificial intelligence are under close scrutiny.

In particular, the use of what is known as deepfakes, or video or audio that is rendered with AI to make it appear as if someone did or said something that never happened, has stirred new debate among researchers about the potential misuse or abuse of the technology.

It also comes shortly after a Google engineer sparked controversy for arguing the company’s sophisticated chatbot communicated as if it was sentient, a claim that did not have the support of the AI research community but nonetheless underscored the freakishly human-like communication skills of the software.

Big Tech companies are increasingly studying AI’s impact on society. Microsoft recently announced it was restricting the use of software that mimics a person’s voice, saying the feature could be weaponized by those trying to impersonate speakers as an act of deception.

Subbarao Kambhampati, a professor of computer science at Arizona State University, said he hopes Amazon showing off a demo of the voice-replicating tool makes the public vigilant to the use of synthetic voices in everyday life.

“As creepy as it might sound, it’s a good reminder that we can’t trust our own ears in this day and age,” Kambhampati said. “But the sooner we get used to this concept, which is still strange to us right now, the better we will be.”

Kambhampati said the Alexa feature has the potential to aid a bereft family member, though it has to be weighed against a variety of moral questions the technology presents.

“For people in grieving, this might actually help in the same way we look back and watch videos of the departed,” he said. “But it comes with serious ethical issues, like is it OK to do this without the deceased person’s consent?”